Collegiate Opera Scenes Competition

2015 Competition Winners

Congratulations to the winners and all finalists who competed at the Greensboro convention in January 2015!


First Place

Georgia State University - Atlanta, Georgia
The Mikado, Act I, “Were You Not to Ko-Ko Plighted” Gilbert & Sullivan

Yum-Yum: Carolyn Balkovetz Nanki-Poo: Kirby Eicholtz
Stage Director: Carroll Freeman Music Director: Grant Jones Pianist: Rebecca Wilt

Second Place

Samford University - Birmingham. Alabama
Falstaff, Act I, “Letter Quartet” Giuseppe Verdi

Alice Ford: Abi Benke Dame Quickly: Maggie Gill
Meg Page: Lauren Marino Nanetta: Christy Vest
Stage and Music Director: Kristin Kenning Pianist: Wesley Ballew


First Place

The University of Nevada, Las Vegas - Las Vegas, Nevada
Into the Woods, Act II, “Any Moment/Moments in the Woods” Stephen Sondheim

Baker’s Wife: Cheyna Alexander Cinderella’s Prince: Xavier Brown
Stage and Music Director: Linda Lister Pianist: Jae Ahn-Benton

Second Place

Sam Houston State University - Huntsville, Texas
Guys and Dolls , Act II, “Sky and the Crapshooters” Frank Loesser

Nicely-Nicely Johnson: Bailey Turner Sky Masterson: John-Michael Jermain
Big Jule: Rene Vazquez Harry the Horse: Allen Castle Benny Southstreet: Jacob Averitt
Nathan Detroit: Gregory T. Broughton
Stage Director: Rebecca Grimes - Music Director and Pianist: Robert Hunt
Choreographer: Travis Prokop


First Place

The University of Nevada, Las Vegas - Las Vegas, Nevada
Sancta Susanna, scene from Act I Paul Hindemith

Klementia: Stephanie Weiss Susanna: Lillian Roberts
Stage and Music Director: Linda Lister Pianist: Jae Ahn-Benton

Second Place

Wichita State University - Wichita, Kansas
Die Fledermaus, Act I, scene iii Johann Strauss

Falke: Constantine Novotny Eisenstein: Andrew Fisher
Stage Director: Marie Allyn King
Music Director: Michael Hanawalt Pianist: Bridget Hille

2015 Competition Flyer

2015 COSC

2016 Competition

Applications are now open for the 2016 Collegiate Opera Scenes Competition.  Finals will be held at the Annual Convention in Indianapolis, IN, in January 2016.  Deadline to apply is October 18, 2015.


Scene from UNC Greensboro's
Most Happy Fella, 2014 COSC Div II

  • Competition is for college and university programs only.
  • All participants who advance to the finals must be current students at the time of the competition.
  • Directors must be members of NOA and pay the convention fee.
    (Directors bringing five or more students will receive a discount).
  • Each student participant will pay the student registration convention fee.
  • There is a $25.00 fee per application to enter the competition. This fee may be sent in the form of a check made out to NOA to the Chair of the COSC or paid on-line through PayPal on the NOA website. If payment is done online, a receipt of proof of online payment must be included as an attachment to the submission email, along with the application and the video entry.
  • The scene entry shall have been performed between October 15, 2014 and October 15, 2015.
  • The scene submitted for the Preliminary Round does not have to be the same scene presented in the Final Round at the convention, but it must meet the same criteria as outlined in the Guidelines below and be in the same Division. (The Preliminary Round is in place in order for an institution to advance to the finals. Schools may submit a scene in the Preliminary Round from the previous academic year which may involve singers who have since graduated or are no longer enrolled. If advanced, that school may choose to, or may need to, bring a different scene to the finals utilizing students in the same age bracket as all participants in the finals must be current students at the submitting institution.)
  • A college or university may enter more than one scene AND (RULE CHANGE for 2016) singers may appear in more than one scene submitted in the preliminaries.  However, only one scene from a given school will be offered a chance to advance to the finals in each division.  If a school submits entries in more than one category and advances to the finals, no singer may appear in more than one category of the competition finals, regardless of the average age of the students in the scene.
  • If a student at a college or university also holds faculty status of any kind at that institution, that student is ineligible and may not appear in a submitted scene.


Competition Categories:

Opera Division I: All performers are between the ages of 18 and 22 (primarily undergraduates)
Opera Division II: All performers are age 23 and older (primarily graduate students)
Musical Theatre: All performers are between the ages of 18 and 22 (primarily undergraduates) See Musical Theatre repertoire guidelines below.

(In the case of an opera scene cast with mixed ages, the Committee will determine the division category by considering the average age of the cast, as well as the size of the role(s) being sung by older performers.)


Operatic literature of all styles and periods is eligible for submission into both opera categories. Standard operetta literature, such as material by Gilbert & Sullivan, Friml, Lehàr, Johann Strauss, and others, will be included in the appropriate opera category. Repertoire in the new Musical Theatre category is restricted to singing in the traditional or “legit” style. Scenes which include heavy belting or pop-rock techniques will not be eligible. Repertoire which includes appropriate and healthy use of chest voice, however, is acceptable. As in the operatic divisions, the quality of singing and vocal technique will be strongly considered.

Definition of a Scene:

A scene is defined as a portion of a larger, published work. Short operas, musicals, or complete works under 10 minutes in length are not eligible for the scenes competition. Composers are encouraged to submit new operas to the Chamber Opera Competition. All submitted scenes must be from a show which has already received a full production by a professional opera or musical theatre company or a university/college program.

Length of Scene:

Suggested length of scenes submitted in both the Preliminary and Final Rounds is 6–8 minutes. Preliminary judges will stop reviewing submissions at the 8 minute mark. The timekeeper at the finals will stop any scene which surpasses 8 minutes, but no penalty will accrue. There is no minimum time requirement.

Hansel and Gretel
Scene from Hansel and Gretel
SUNY Purchase
2014 COSC Div. I


Set pieces are limited to rehearsal blocks and convention hotel tables and chairs located in the meeting room in which the competition will take place. No other set pieces are to be utilized in the scene. Costumes and hand-held props are at the discretion of the director.

Performance Space:

The committee will request the largest stage available at the hotel that is not less than a 24 feet x 16 feet platform.

Judging Criteria and Procedures:

The scene will be judged on musical style and accuracy, diction, vocal quality, basic stagecraft, individual characterization and ensemble interaction, and creative use of set, props, and costumes based on the competition limitations.

Scenes that are not in the standard repertoire (new works) shall provide three copies of the music for judging purposes.

For a detailed description of the judging procedures at both the preliminary and final rounds, click here.

Preliminary Round

Application is by email which should contain a completed application (available as a Word document) as  an attachment and a link to a YouTube video or another video format. The video must be anonymous with no identifying names or photos associated with it. Please do not submit a scene which requires a password. The video may be public or on a private channel as long as it meets all standards of anonymity and is directly accessible to the judge via the submitted link. The email should be received no later than 5:00 pm CST October 18, 2015 at:

The uploaded video should be labeled only with the name of the opera and scene to preserve anonymity for the preliminary judging round. There should be no other identifying features in the link or on the video itself in order to prevent disqualification.

Please feel free to contact Paul Houghtaling with any questions or if you need assistance with uploading your video to a YouTube link.

If submitting the $25 application fee by check, please send to:

Dr. Paul Houghtaling
Chair, 2016 Collegiate Opera Scenes Competition
University of Alabama School of Music
PO Box 870366
810 Second Avenue
Tuscaloosa, AL 354587-0366


Final Round

Fille du Regiment
Scene from Fille du Regiment
University of TX Brownsville
2014 COSC Div. I

  • A maximum of twelve finalists, four (4) in each division, will advance and compete in a live performance at the National Convention in Indianapolis, IN, on Thursday, January 7, 2016.
  • Upon being moved to the finals, an official letter of invitation to the Convention shall be extended by email to the director by November 15, 2015.
  • Finalists will notify the COSC Chair of their acceptance and submit the Finalist Information Form no later than 5:00 p.m., November 22, 2015.
  • Winners will be recognized directly after the competition. First and second place will be awarded in each of the three divisions. First place winners will receive an engraved plaque with second place winners receiving a certificate. All finalists will receive a participation certificate.
  • Video of the winning scenes may be posted on the NOA website following the January convention pending availability and a signed release by the institution granting permission to NOA to post the video. Institutions may also need to obtain permission to post the video for material not in the public domain in accordance with all relevant intellectual property statutes.


Questions regarding the competition may be addressed to:
Paul Houghtaling, competition chair, at , or to
Robert Hansen, Executive Director, at or by calling 806-651-2857.